The Ken Blanchard Companies® Situational Leadership®II model teaches managers that improvement in a direct report's performance requires them to provide the matching direction and support the employee needs. But what should managers do when faced with a decline in performance? Just as improvements in performance prompt forward shifts in leadership style, decreases in performance require a shift backward in leadership style.
The Emotional Component Experienced managers will tell you that dealing with declining performance is often a difficult and highly emotionally charged undertaking. If the situation has been going on for some time, there is probably a high level of emotional tension in the relationship between the leader and the direct report. We've found that a four-step framework can help defuse the emotional component of addressing declining performance.
Step One: Preparation The first step to addressing declining performance is preparation. Preparation should involve selecting a specific performance or behavior that you want to focus on. Do not attempt to address everything at once.
Step Two: Discussion Once you have done a thorough job of preparing, you're ready to schedule a meeting to discuss the situation. It is important to begin the meeting by stating the meeting's purpose and setting ground rules. This will ensure that both parties will be heard in a way that doesn't arouse defensiveness. People who have lost commitment and have serious performance or behavior issues are very likely to be argumentative and defensive when confronted.
Step Three: Reaching Agreement With your ground rules set, the next step is to identify where there is agreement and disagreement on both the issue and its causes. Your job is to see if enough of a mutual understanding can be reached so that mutual problem solving can go forward. When you think it is possible to go forward, ask, "Are you willing to work with me to get this resolved?"
Step Four: Partnering for Performance The answer you get in step three will help you determine the appropriate leadership style to use in step four: Partnering for Performance. If you get a commitment to work together to resolve the issue, you and the direct report need to have a Partnering for Performance discussion where you jointly decide the leadership style you will use to provide work direction or coaching.
Challenging but Worth It Dealing with declining performance is one of the biggest challenges facing managers. For the most part, leaders avoid dealing with it largely because it is such an emotionally charged issue and they don't know how. However, if you conduct the performance conversation in honest good faith and continue to follow the four steps, you will reduce the impact of less-than-perfect interpersonal skills and set the foundation for productive relationships built on commitment and trust.